June 12, 2019
Rarely will we hear hymns being sung at church services anymore. When Contemporary Christian Music (CCM) came into the church, it came to stay and the hymnals were exchanged for the modern beat and rhythm. Still, CCM has revolutionized and doesn’t resemble the pioneering Christian music of the 60s and 70s. Through the years, CCM has been criticized by the older generations and lauded by the younger ones. Those who oppose CCM believe it to be too worldly. Those who accept it, don’t see anything wrong with modernized music. Regardless of the debate over CCM, I believe all of us can agree that Christian music is nothing like the old -fashioned gospel songs Christians used to sing.
The question here is whether this is good or bad? However, the ultimate question is; what does God think about our worship offering?
If you have ever wondered why worship music just isn’t the same anymore, you’re in good company. But the questions I ask you now is; what’s wrong with today’s Christian music? And what is missing? Because I believe that there’s something VERY wrong with modern Christian music and you will too after you consider what I’m about to write.
Before I proceed, I would like to clarify that this is NOT an attack on CCM nor anyone who listens to it. I will look at Christian music on an individual basis and pray you may see these points with an open heart, and without preconceptions.
I grew up in the 90s and early 2000s, during the time of DC Talk, Jars of Clay, Newsboys, Audio Adrenaline, Switchfoot, Kutless, and Reliant K to name a few. These were my English Christian jams (because I also had my Spanish ones). If I’m honest, I was mainly moved by the music rather than the lyrics. I’d be lying if I said that the 90s didn’t produce some pretty catchy tunes. In my pre-teen and teenage mind, there existed no conviction nor discernment about the words in these songs. In my mind, if the band/artist claimed to be Christian and if the song mentioned something about God or the Bible, then it was acceptable. This remained my criteria for many years until a couple of years ago something happened that dramatically changed my view about Christian music.
I was jamming to something like Casting Crowns or the likes ( I don’t exactly remember what I was listening to) but it was a song with a lovely beat and lyrics. I was not worshiping God, I was simply moving with the music. When suddenly I heard that beautiful small still voice, I had grown to love.
The Father rebuked me in that gentle yet firm voice, “That is MY worship, not yours. It should glorify ME, not you.”
I stopped immediately and said “You’re so right, Lord. Forgive me.” From then on, the Lord grew my convictions about the music that was pleasing to Him. I realized that not just because an artist claims to be Christian or because a song mentions a biblical story that it is Christian or acceptable unto the Lord. I guess sometimes we don’t take God’s music seriously or lack the discernment to know that not just any song will suffice. God cares about the music, the lyrics, the heart of worship, and the intent of the heart with which we worship Him. His music is holy. The musician, as well as the worshippers, must present themselves as pure and holy before His throne. Music is to worship God, and not to get high on the beat.
“Praise ye the Lord. Praise God in his sanctuary: praise him in the firmament of his power. Praise him for his mighty acts: praise him according to his excellent greatness. Praise him with the sound of the trumpet: praise him with the psaltery and harp. Praise him with the timbrel and dance: praise him with stringed instruments and organs. Praise him upon the loud cymbals: praise him upon the high sounding cymbals.”
(Psalm 150:1-5)
There are several things I noticed wrong with today’s Christian music.
(For the sake of brevity and avoidance of redundancy, I will refer to today’s Christian music as CCM. Again, I am NOT against CCM in its entirety, but I do believe there’s something wrong with most of it. So I will address those issues individually and name a few bands where applicable. But I do not want you to think that I’m saying Christians should toss out CCM entirely.)
CCM is Largely Influenced by Worldly Music
I won’t talk about whether it’s okay for Christians to listen to secular music or not, that’s another article that I will be writing soon. But I believe most Christians have the conviction that music that is supposed to glorify God should not borrow concepts from secular music. We are to sing a new song unto the Lord.
“O sing unto the Lord a new song; for he hath done marvellous things: his right hand, and his holy arm, hath gotten him the victory.”
(Psalm 96:1)
We can hardly do that when we take the same beat, music style, rhythm, and sometimes even similar lyrics from worldly songs! I’ve come across some “Christian” songs that have been recycled from secular ones. Many of these secular songs have been offered up to Satan and here are these hip Christian artists singing them to God.
That’s strange fire! We have to be careful with what we listen and sing.
CCM Appeals to the Flesh
I’ve noticed that most modern songs mainly appeal to the flesh. That “feel good” emotionalism it evokes is so real. And it’s easy to be fooled into believing that it’s the presence of God, when in fact, it’s just emotion. A lot of these songs are composed to produce emotional highs- to glorify the flesh and not God.
And for the most part, that’s what the Christian music industry is all about; to produce songs with an awesome rhythm, instrumentals, a catchy, repetitive chorus with the same chords, throw in a word about God and there you have it. It’s all about selling albums, and how do you do that? By writing catchy songs that appeal to emotion.
Take “Oceans” by Hillsong for example. Those long minutes before and in between the lyrics of pure electronic bliss sure do send goosebumps straight to your toes! And its forte is repetition. By the end of the song, all I received from it was a warm-tingly feeling. No mention about the real human struggle on waiting and the unknown, the battles and trials that come with having your faith stretched. The message (if it can even be called that) is so mellow, gentle, and calm. But faith comes through war and feverish gut-wrenching prayer.
“My faith will be made stronger in the presence of my Savior”? Seriously? This is cheap, believism Christianity-God is a genie in a bottle- rub it and you shall have what you want. No talk about suffering, carrying your cross, and death for the sake of the Kingdom. This takes me to my third point…
CCM Has Bad Theology
This is what I have the most problem with; Christian songs that have bad theology, who paint an easy and wide path to Christ. And then there are the more problematic songs who mention New Age philosophy. These you have to be very careful with. Sometimes these songs have it very well hidden, it takes great discernment and knowledge of Scripture to detect. Music is an effective way to infiltrate the church with a false Gospel and doctrines of demons.
One huge problem I have is the fact that most CCM songs today don’t even mention God by name. “He” and “you” can be anyone. They could be singing to Satan for all we know. Many songs go through a long chorus and verses and bridge without a single mention of God. Makes you wonder to whom they are singing.
Also, be careful that you don’t end up singing along with songs with ecumenical theology. Ecumenism has infiltrated every facet of Christianity I’m afraid, and music didn’t escape. There are many Christian artists (search Phil Whickam, Matt Maher, One Thing conference, Jesus Adrain Romero, Alex Campos, Marcos Witt, to name a few) who have now sided with the Catholic Church and produce music to “bridge the gap” between Protestants and Catholics.
The minister of music must be grounded on the Rock, have unshakable faith, be diligent in prayer, and take his/her responsibilities seriously. They lead the church in worship unto God, theirs is an important role! The last thing we want is to follow a music minister (musician)who has no idea what he/she believes! (Take Lauren Daigle for example). I’m not judging, but by their fruits, they shall be known. So, know the theology of the musicians you listen to.
CCM Turns Musicians into Idols
[bctt tweet=”I repent of ever having recorded one single song, and ever having performed one concert, if my music, and more importantly, my life has not provoked you into Godly jealousy or to sell out more completely to Jesus! ~Keith Green” username=”TheScribe_Blog”]
Like I said earlier, the Christian music industry is all about selling albums. It’s about concerts, tours, merchandise, marketing, and making artists into idols. It’s fine to like a band’s/artist’s music but it’s another matter entirely to idolize them- asking for signatures, pictures, posters, and yell really loud when they come on stage. It is bad enough that they sell the Message already, but sadly, many Christian musicians are prideful as well. They love the accolades and the spotlight. I’m not judging nor do I claim to know their hearts but you can’t say you’re humble and then give away signatures and get the rockstar treatment.
So do you think the Lord receives this music? I’ll let you chew on that.
I love Keith Green’s music, though he’s been gone for over 30 years, his humble heart for the Lord can still be felt through his beautiful, poured out worship. To this day, I have yet to find another Christian musician who has this much jealous devotion for the Lord. I mention him because he said something that is very true and every Christian singer should listen to this.
He said,
“If someone writes a great story, people praise the author, not the pen. People don’t say ‘Oh what an incredible pen, where can I get a pen like that so I can write great stories?’ Well, I am just a pen in the hands of the Lord. He is the author. All praise should go to Him.”
CCM and the World
In 2016, Hillsong came under fire after a concert featuring a “naked cowboy” spilled into social media. If you’ve seen the clips on YouTube you’ll no doubt, agree with me when I say that Hillsong has really crossed the line. The spectacle looked more like a strip bar than a Christian concert. Sadly, Hillsong has repeatedly found itself embroiled in controversy.
This is only a small taste of the state of contemporary Christian music. Time and space would fail me to discuss Bethel, Elevation Worship, Passion, etc. (I encourage you to do your own research regarding the theology of these churches and their bands) Granted, no one band or artist is perfect but I believe most of these modern Christian bands have allowed the world to seep into their ministries. A lot of this music is no longer holy as it has been infected with worldliness.
For a long time, I stopped listening to music altogether because I didn’t know what was good for my soul anymore. I didn’t know what songs were spiritually edifying and pleasing to God.
So for a time, I went back to listening only to hymns and old Gospel songs. It’s crazy how refreshing it is to go back to the old worship songs of our ancestors. The simple, beautiful, and Scriptural lyrics that glorify only God does much good to the soul.
I’m not here to tell you what you should or shouldn’t listen to, I’ll just say this; seek God with an open heart and mind. Ask God which music pleases Him. But I do want to tell you that there is pure and acceptable worship and then there’s strange fire. Be careful what you allow your ears to hear. These are deceiving times, not all is as it appears.
Just a Couple of Recommendations
I hope and pray you have grasped a little of what I’m trying to convey. This has not been an easy post to write because it’s controversial but I felt the strong urge to say it all anyway.
With that, I’d like to make a couple of music recommendations. My style may not be yours but I really enjoy the pioneers of CCM (their music was so different from today’s CCM) Messianic Music I have found, tends to be the most Scriptural, and Indie (Folk) Christian Music are among my favorites.
I really love the music of:
- Keith Green
- Second Chapter of Acts
- All Sons and Daughters
- Christ for the Nations
- Jason Upton
- Joshua Aaron
- Paul Wilbur
- Rivers & Robots
- Here Be Lions
- Seeker & Servant
- Shane & Shane
- Josh Garrels
- Jonathan Ogden
- The Gaithers
Enjoyed this post? Share it on Pinterest!
Noraliz Pacheco
God Bless you my sister in Christ. What an awesome article. Praise the Lord!…I am glad to know that there are christians that are waking up in regard to CCM. Most of CCM is targeted to satisfied the flesh, “make me feel good” songs and not convicting songs that brings us to the feet of Jesus. God Helps us all. There needs to be more talk and more articles like this one. Continue the good work for God’s glory. Thank you for sharing your favorites. Some of them I do know and others I will be listening to.
Tony Carrozza
Man, you nailed it! I grew up in Christ during the Jesus Movement of the early 70’s. I was in a rock band at the time when one by one we each became believers. There being few examples of contemporary Christian music at the time, we wrote our own songs and used rock and roll as a vehicle to reach kids on the street. They listened and many became believers and still are to this day. But the music we offered up when the body came together to worship was so wonderfully different than what we have today. The musicians, if there were any, were irrelevant – it was the combined voices worshiping in spirit and truth – most often parts of Scripture set to song- that set the room and our hearts ablaze with His Holy Spirit. Today it’s much harder to find that. I crave meat but get fed muffins. Empty spiritual calories.
John
Visit a church website and you might find a photo of there worship band. The photo will contain bright multicolored spotlights , fog, smoke, or a dark low light setting. The musicians probably have a heart for Jesus. But it looks like a secular rock concert. This is a plan to appeal to the younger generation of Christians. If the worship music is so loud and by chance you cannot understand the words how do you worship and glorify God? Psalms were used to glorify God as well as some instruments. All of the glory goes to God.
Rod
If you want to get stung, poke the nest! I have been on both sides of this investigation, and I honestly don’t think we will ever completely get away from it! I appreciate the heart behind the article, and don’t really have any disagreements with the content. I do, however, have a problem when we start drawing lines in the sand, throwing mud at different mindsets and allowing the conversation to be directed away from the Lord and to our own desires/perspectives. I have heard this conversation in a biblically-sound non-denominational church, I have heard this conversation in an Independent Fundamental Baptist church among others. My conviction is this: let’s understand that we all have different faith fabrics, we are all at different maturity levels and we all have different preferences. Let’s get the conversation steered back to the reason for worship – the Holiness of God! I have my own music preferences, I am concerned about the worldly trends into music, but the best thing I can do is listen to what the still, small Voice is telling me and be obedient! Let’s be grateful that we still have the Helper directing us to Truth, and let’s be faithful – Jesus is coming back, and THAT Worship will be AMAZING!!
Seth
I agree. All we need to do is find the justification for why music started to conform in the first place to examine where people’s hearts were. If they had no fear of the Lord while changing worship this way then it wouldnt be wise to accept this change. Worship music has nothing to do with personal taste. We are called to sacrifice ourselves: He that findeth his life shall lose it, and he that loseth his life for my sake shall find it.(Matthew 10:39) It’s about what God would like to hear, not us. If we don’t like his style then we must learn to like it because we love him. Do we think the angels are singing ccm in heaven or anything that resembles modern day music? We are followers of God so to attempt to conform Holy music so that we can enjoy it more is blasphemous. He will not change a tittle of his masterpiece in heaven to fit our personal taste. We need to stay in our place at all times because God doesn’t play games with people that try to tell him what is good. The motto at the gates of hell should read “At least I had it my way”.
Evelyn Fonseca
Say it louder! Worship is for the Lord not us, I agree 100%
Petra Lucien
Thank you so much for this article. I’m on the brink of trying to share a song that came into my heart one day to be sung at a child’s Dedication (or a Christening, and as I’ve looked around to see how other people have shared their songs it makes me really sad: so often people take credit for things which were clearly given to them by the Holy Spirit, and use them to glorify themselves. The quote you gave from Keith Green is absolutely correct, we are nothing but tools in God’s hands (in my case a very poor quality tool).
I grew up in the UK, and was not familiar with Keith Green’s songs other than ‘There is a redeemer’ but I have been listening to some of his songs this afternoon and reading his article ‘So you wanna be a rock star’. Thank you for pointing me in his direction.
Very Concerned
All that glitters is not gold. Worship music is supposed to be just that….Worship Music!
It is meant to glorify, exalt, and magnify God and bring us into a state of awe and wonder where we begin to encounter Him and know His Presence as we sing–anything less than that is NOT worship music.
Unfortunately, there is ’emotional music’ that mentions God that is being called ‘worship music’ because it contains some uplifting lyrics but it is NOT worship music, it is emotional music and it is NOT ‘God-Breathed, that is, it does not have the ability to bring about the Presence of God in worship-it only brings about a temporary emotional uplift.
Unfortunately, this has became the norm in too many Churches and Christians are leaving because God is not in it and they are no longer experiencing the deep, Presence of God during the music part of the service-they are not being fed.
I had to leave a Church because of this.
The music had changed and God was no longer in it., and this is happening in many, many Churches.
There were false teachers that were infiltrating the early Church and still today, so don’t you think false worship music is any different in entering into the congregations??
The problem is that not only people are embracing it, but defending it!!
So my questions are concerning the music during that part of the worship( because music is only a part of worship-it is NOT all of worship) are:
Are the worship leaders and the instrumentalists being exalted or is Jesus??
Is Jesus in the fog machines, lights, and/or lasers??
Is Jesus in the guitar solos??
Are the people clapping at the end for Jesus or the worship team??
Are you encountering the deep, Presence of God during the music??
If you answer ‘No’ to any of these questions, then God is NOT being worshiped and is actually being ‘upstaged’ by the performance and performers.
God does not cause division among His Church!
We do when we bring things in that are NOT of God that cause believers to leave because we are led to believe that we are the problem NOT the music or the laity refuse to believe the music is the problem because it is ‘worship music’ by Christian artists..
Moreover, new music is being cranked out by label companies and groups so fast that believers are being forced to learn new songs at an alarmingly high rate insomuch we can barely keep up while the songs we learned just a few months ago fade into the background to make room for more..
Christian music production has become extremely competitive and is a large marketing industry.
It was not so in the beginning, but has now became so lucrative that secularism, compromise, and generic lyrics have invaded our worship services and people are leaving because God is not in it and rightfully so.
I watched what is being called a Christian music video and after all the lights, lasers, monitors, and smoke was over, all that was missing was a panel of 3 judges!
Sure, you can chime in after this comment and find ways to attempt to justify today’s so-called worship music ( and some of it truly is ), but once again, ask those questions above.
Are the people clapping at the end for Jesus or the worship team??
Is Jesus in all those lights, lasers, fog machines,monitors, and guitar solos??
Are you encountering the deep, Presence of God during the music or are you going home with a temporary emotional uplift that soon fades away not long after you leave the service??
All that glitters is NOT gold.
Peace be with you all. Amen
Evelyn Fonseca
I couldn’t have said it better! Thank you for this comment, hopefully all who find this article will read this. Blessings!
Wesley Cowan
I respectfully disagree and believe while this article is well intentioned I don’t agree with many points. The Psalms don’t always mention God in everyone and show many styles of worship including anger, praise, doubt and sometimes no easy answers. God is never mentioned by name once in two books in the canon of the Bible, Esther and Songs of Solomon. Yet his power, love and other aspects are clear and why they are in the Bible. For Christian songs to always explicitly state God and praise songs especially is too narrow a view. Precludes the possibility God can be heard be felt, worshipped and be in communication with in a personal way through any means God decides to. Yes some music and lyrics are off the mark but sometimes secular lyrics, music, film, friends and other things communicate very powerful which might be as much as who the receiver is as well as God using any means he chooses including mystery and things we have no easy explanations for. That said, I respect the writer and readers to have their own views, thinking, and ways of having a relationship with God.
Evelyn Fonseca
The books of Esther and SOS have nothing to do with music, so comparing both to modern music is like comparing apples and oranges. Biblical times were not tainted by the worldliness that we deal with now. David and the writers of Psalms were not exposed to demonic and worldly music we are exposed to now so we can hardly say that they were tempted and/or influenced by the kind of music that we are now.
I wouldn’t consider saying that songs should mention God makes it a narrow view because our desire to exalt God’s name comes naturally when we worship in spirit and truth. Now that is not to say that those who don’t explicitly mention God in some songs don’t worship truthfully, what I’m saying is, not mentioning God runs the danger of putting the focus on self and our emotions, which is what most CCM songs do.
Really, my whole article, if read carefully, makes the case for God-centered, theologically sound music, free from human focus and emotional exploitation. Sadly, when studied carefully, CCM does both and lacks God-centeredness. CCM has shifted their focused to money and big business which is only successful when appealing to the human flesh.
Cynthia Jantz
Hello: I am a Bible believing, Born again Christian and member of a Fundamental, Independent Baptist Church! When God first directed me to the Church back in March 2008, I was of the belief that all that mattered was the lyrics, and that the instrumentals were of far less importance! But God’s Holy Word transformed my life and my worldview! We are to Worship God in Spirit and in Truth! What passes as Christian music today is only pleasing our flesh and the world! We only sing Psalms and Hymns and spiritual songs that please our holy God and Savior Jesus Christ! We have a piano and an organ, and occasionally we are blessed with a violin! You will never find guitars ( especially electric guitars) or drums, etc. We are there to bring glory to God! All CCM is pleasing only to the Prince of Darkness, and to the flesh! 2 Cor. 6:14-18; 7:1 Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness? and what communion hath Light with Darkness? And what concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath he that believeth with an infidel? And what agreement hath the temple of God with idols? for ye are the temple of the Living God; as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them; and I will be their God, and they shall be My people. Wherefore come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing; and I will receive you, And will be a Father unto you, and ye shall be My sons and daughters, saith the Lord Almighty. Having therefore these Promises, dearly beloved, let us Cleanse ourselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the Fear of God.
Keith Post
This is pretty spot on. I’m Apostolic and as you may know we are compelled scripturally to be seperate from the word and it’s ways inwardly outwardly all areas of our life unto the Lord, now I wasn’t born into this but I do see the come out from amongst them, what has always amazed me is this, we wouldn’t and shouldn’t allow sombody who considered us a cult or in false doctrine etc to minister from our pulpit any sooner than another denomination would. I won’t get into modesty etc but I’d be safe to say the vast majority of Christian musicians and their church’s just don’t line up with our Biblical beliefs.. so here’s my thoughts. Why do we use their music almost exclusively yet we almost shun our own recording artists, I’m pretty sure they are not using any of our music in their worship services but we do, and almost are proud how contemporary our worship service is, now I’m not saying all the music is bad but why is music especially in the church the one main area we just don’t see the need to be separated? If the only criteria is well the songs are lifting up the Lord , than no artist as long as they sing about Jesus should be off limits, secular or not, Metallica has a few songs that are just as Biblical as any other Christian artist. Matter of fact I’ve seen lyrics and as most wouldn’t like the particular style of music some Christian metal bands are way more scriptural than alot of the CCM music or some of the other artist in Christian radii. Remember now it’s supposed to lift up Jesus so that would eliminate style over content. I personally have a hard time wuthering southern gospel the music reminds of of when I used to drink in the bars. It’s amazing to me how we do not seperate when it’s comes to music ive always said Satan was the worship leader j. Heaven, if he can just water sheen what allow nto our spirit he’s winning. Loved your article.
Evelyn Fonseca
You bring up some really good points! Thanks for your comment.
Teresa
I respectfully disagree about your comment that the Bible says nothing about swearing, etc.
Ephesians 4:29 Do not let any unwholesome talk come out of your mouths, but only what is helpful for building others up according to their needs, that it may benefit those who listen.
Swearing and cussing are the same thing.
Angel
I totally agree that we need to discern the music we listen to in order to make sure it’s Scripturally and theologically sound. We also need to make sure the “worship” is directed to God rather than pointing to ourselves. I’ve heard many modern songs focus more on self than on Christ, but I’ve also heard traditional hymns that do the same. I don’t think it’s fair to paint every modern Christian song as self-centered or theologically empty (Not saying you are— but some people do!) There are many songs by groups like Maverick City Music, Elevation, Bethel, City Alight, etc. that have really reminded me of biblical truths and have powerful, gospel-centered lyrics. I’m not here to defend any music group because there is certainly a problem with them being idolized. I don’t think any of us should blindly listen to any song without examining the message and making sure it aligns with Scripture. I also don’t see anything wrong with music adapting to modern style. Traditional hymns were at one time contemporary and modern. Worship changes from culture to culture and generation to generation. I think that’s beautiful, honestly. And that is one thing I disagree with you on, that modern music only appeals to the flesh. I used to think this way when I saw people seemingly getting an “emotional high” from modern worship songs. But here’s an honest question I started thinking one day— what’s wrong with that? What’s wrong with music stirring up our emotions to God? What’s wrong with stirring up our souls to worship, like the psalmists did? I don’t think there is a problem with music penetrating our souls and stirring our affections… as long as our affections are pure and truly toward God. It’s about the heart, not the worship style.
Jim
This is a well written and thoughtful article. I wish I could agree with all of it, but I really can’t. You have some very valid points — points that resonate with why I’ve turned away from so much of the drivel called “Christian music”. When you talk about the bad theology, you are right on! Mandisa had a popular song some time back that was steeped in new age theology, but nonetheless played over and over on Christian music stations and was “loved” by so many Christians who were not grounded enough in the Word to recognize the lie.
Let me be clear I am not slamming Mandisa. She was a baby Christian at the time. I’m sure she didn’t even realize the words she was singing were more New Age than Biblical truth. That is where mature Christians are *supposed* to come in — to lovingly correct the error instead of just ignoring it.
Where I must differ with you is when we quibble about specific style. This is, unfortunately, where so many start and stop. “Rock music is of the devil”. “Fast music only appeals to the flesh”. On and on it goes. I know you didn’t specifically say that, but you did imply certain beats taken from modern music styles do nothing but appeal to the flesh. Yet, I can testify that when I was younger, sold-out (to Jesus) rock bands produced songs that were scripturally based, theologically sound, and touched many young souls in positive, Christ-honoring ways. The same can be said no matter what style we want to examine. I must also say that any musical style can “appeal to our flesh”. I have a wide musical pallet, and I can be just as enthralled with Classical as I can with Rock-n-Role.
I probably should note some musical styles are intentionally dark, clashing, and literally designed to convey and invoke anger. Other styles are designed to “empty the mind” and produce trance-like states. I doubt such extreme styles could possibly be turned to His glory, though I could be wrong.
I also find some thread in your article that does not differentiate between worship music we should sing in church vs. music we listen to (and often worship along with) at home. There are great rock songs and great very slow hymns that touch people’s soul with His truth. However, they are not appropriate for congressional worship because their style is literally painful for others. This is where we as Christians have really fallen down. Corporate worship is *not* about what we want, or what we like!
Philippians 2:3 Do nothing out of selfish ambition or empty pride, but in humility consider others more important than yourselves.
Yet, we go to church and expect the worship team to play what we like. The worship leaders put their own desires ahead of anyone who doesn’t like the style they have chosen. “Too loud for you? Too bad, here are some earplugs.” Or on the other side, “Too slow for you, too bad because we only do Larghissimo. If you want faster you just arn’t worshipping.” If we were ALL to put other first, we would end up with beautifully diverse worship services that obtain a middle ground where everyone can be drawn to worship Him. That is what corporate worship should be about. Laying down our own desires as we worship Him with brothers and sisters who are likewise worshiping Him. Not in spite of the music, but part because of it.
God created music — I find it so sad that we have allowed Satan to divide us, split us and plant bad theology in our hearts and mind using music.
I love your article because it calls us to think about our music. Not to argue about it, defend it, or go on our merry mindless path. To think about it, in light of His word. You hit the nail right on the head — something is very wrong with today’s popular Christian music. In large part, it lacks the very essence of what it should be.
AMG
I agree with MOST of the points of your article. Many of the artists you listed as your favorites are mine too. I don’t listen to any secular music and am VERY picky about the CCM I listen to. Having said that, I think your whole argument would have been a lot more convincing if you had not used the “strange fire,” comment to make your point about the evils of CCM confiscating worldly music. First, you have completely and utterly taken that scripture out of context to make your point. I seriously cringed when I read that. I encourage you to go back and prayerfully read Leviticus 9 and 10 again.
Second, your whole point about CCM confiscating worldly type music is flawed since you DO listen to hymns. The whole reason hymns (which I thoroughly love) came into existence was because Luther wanted congregations to be able to sing songs of worship in their own language instead of Latin chants-which back in the day were considered the ONLY acceptable form of musical worship. (sound familiar) Many of our old hymns use the same chord structure, meter, and rhythm as the the SECULAR folk tunes of that day.
The truth is, the Bible is silent about the sinfulness/righteousness of one kind of music versus another. I do agree with you, however, on your main point. Worship is all about God. Any song that does not point to Him as the only object of our worship shouldn’t be labeled as worship.
So whether we’re getting rowdy, emotional, and overly-zealous with their worship (Exodus 15, Samuel 6:15) OR we’re worshipping with a sense of reverent awe (Luke 1:67-79, Luke 1:46-55) the Only one who get’s to decide if we’re worshipping in Spirit and Truth is HIM. And I promise you He is not looking at the chord structure of our song. He’s looking at our hearts.
Evelyn Fonseca
Firstly, thank you for your respectful comment. Many don’t know how to voice a contrary opinion without getting angrily defensive. Secondly, sorry it has taken me this long to reply, your comment got lost amongst others.
Regarding my reference to the strange fire of Leviticus 10, I disagree that it was taken out of context. Aaron’s sons offered an unauthorized sacrifice to the Lord resulting in their untimely deaths. This shows us that God takes offerings very seriously and is greatly displeased when done in an unholy, unscripturally manner. What is worship but an offering to the Lord?
When I said that some CCM songs have copied secular songs I meant, that they took the exact tune and then just changed the lyrics to make it “Christian.”
The Bible is silent about many topics that’s where discernment is needed and the daily pursuit of the guidance of the Holy Spirit to lead us closer in sanctification. The Bible says nothing about smoking, swearing, and using drugs, yet any Christian with an ounce of discernment knows these to be wrong.
GEORGE
I applaud your article. As a 75-year old, I have struggled many years with Christian music. As a teen I regarded hymns as boring; 20s-30s and older, led the singing in various venues of oldsters and youngsters; in my sixties, I did 8 years of prison ministry wherein we sang modern songs, mostly acapella because I didn’t want them dependent on accompaniment (I did the same in a retirement village where I was shocked the people didn’t think they could worship without a piano player! I have no trouble with CCM if the lyrics have rhyme, rhythm, worship content, and volume that doesn’t damage ears (80db or less). Personally, I like “Oceans” and wouldn’t have chosen it for an example. [“You call me out upon the waters” reminiscent of Peter being called to join the Savior walking on water OR me entering prison ministry. Yes, prison ministry is pretty tame compared to other callings but there were opportunities enough to test faith] [“the great unknown where feet may fail… and I will call upon Your Name, and keep my eyes above the waves” … well, it sort of rhymes, and the meaning is profound to anyone who has found themselves in unexpected trying circumstances. To me, “Oceans” is very worshipful. “My lighthouse “ or “We Will” are songs I have trouble with, not to mention the loud bass &/ or drum sets. There is a line in a hymn that instructs “let every instrument be tuned to praise.” Early on in my directing of congregational worship, I introduced a drummer. Recently saved out of the nightclub scene, he brought one drum which he played softly and worshipfully; My wife sang a solo to only his drumming!
>> There is another reason for my interest in your article: I’m trying to interest our church in singing hymns acapella to learn worshipful words that can be sung anywhere, anytime, and hopefully to interest the next generation.…
>> Blessings
Anonymous
Sorry, but because God told you that your worship was focused on you rather than Him is a YOU issue, not a CCM issue. And I have a newsflash for you, not only churches like Hillsong have problems. I know plenty of Southern Baptists who’ve never shown the fruits of the Spirit in their entire lives. I agree, the New York Hillsong church totally messed up, but you shouldn’t throw out the baby with the bath water. I along with millions of others have been blessed by Hillsong, Bethel, Jesus Culture, etc. The basic point of your article is that because you didn’t feel a certain way while listening to CCM, everyone should listen to you and stop listening to it. Oh, and let me tell you about the 90’s groups like dcTalk, News Boys, etc: As a newly saved youth, that music spoke to me more than some 100 year old song. And it wasn’t the music only, it was the lyrics about Jesus. Lastly, you quote Psalm 96:1, yet you out down the very groups that are producing these new songs for Christ. I’m not adding my info, because I don’t want a response arguing with my points, because you’re wrong. If Christians found the same energy to witness to the lost instead of picking apart everything other Christians do, there would be no lost left in the entire world. Also, since I didn’t see any other comments disagreeing with your dogmatic stance, I doubt you’ll post my comment on here.
Evelyn Fonseca
Yeah, you missed the whole point of the post. Firstly, God convicting me about how I “worshipped” and what I listened to was just the beginning of a journey of learning and understanding what unadulterated, holy, and acceptable worship music entailed.
The main point of my post is to expose worship ministers/bands who have mixed elements of the world with God’s Holy music. Which by the way, is strange fire and should not be taken lightly (read Leviticus 10 to see what happened to Aaron’s sons). We are called to expose unbiblical practices and teachings for the benefit of those who don’t know better or lack discernment.
And I fail to see what Southern Baptists have to do with anything I wrote. I did not mention denominations, because that information does not pertain to the topic of this post. Yes, of course, any Christian can lack spiritual fruit however, that is individual responsibility and has nothing to do with denomination. Christian bands/ministers as those who lead others in worship and write songs, have a serious responsibility before God, especially those with a high profile. You cannot compare Hillsong with an ordinary unknown person from a rural Baptist church. Hillsong has influence and popularity, a small church in the south has neither. But that’s beside the point.
I don’t deny that the music of these bands has drawn people to God, church, the Truth and produced a million other experiences for millions of people but if God can use a donkey He can also use sinful humans with twisted theology. This just goes to show the enormity of God’s mercy for humanity. This doesn’t mean, however, that we shouldn’t test the spirits and call out unholiness in the music industry. Just because a song made me feel good and made me cry doesn’t mean that it passes the Scripturally sound check. Your comment that a modern song spoke to you more than a 100-year-old song perfectly proves my point. We are heavily led by feelings and emotions rather than the Word. Hymns are 100% scriptural, which is why they are still powerful in 2023. CCM, on the other hand, appeals to the emotions (the flesh) it keeps people blind and bereft of worship borne from the Word of God and it stunts spiritual growth. Hebrews 4:12 says that The Word of God is sharper than a two-edged sword, something that old hymns contain and CCM lacks.
Lastly, you don’t see comments arguing my points because yours is the first one. I publish all the comments, both positive and negative, and reply for the benefit of all the readers. I have taken the time to type out this response for anyone else who may feel the same way and for anyone else who may get something out of this thread, so thank you for sharing your views. Blessings.
Isaac J
I do not normally listen to CCM as I was taught to not like it by my parents and grandparents. I never really knew the reason behind it, but I didn’t think much of it. Everytime I heard it out in public, on a radio or it automatically shows up as the next song, there was some urge to want to listen to it. It seemed very difficult, but I always stopped or ignored it, and then forgot about it.
Well, a few months ago I was in a music theory class that was talking about melody, and they played part of this song called “You say”. I didn’t know the name of it at the time, but I am desperately trying not to pay any attention to it. I was glad when it stopped because it felt like it was pulling my gut or something (that’s the only way I know to describe this feeling). I do listen to some worldy music, though not CCM of any kind.
Tonight, I watched a video that had that same song in it, and I suddenly remembered hearing that in class. Combined with the nostalgia connected to it and the way it made me feel, I decided to Shazam the song, and right away it gave me the name. I was, at first, hesitant to do this because it goes directly against what I was taught, but then decided to proceed. I had goose bumps all over me, and I’m in such a feel good mood that I had not felt by listening to any other “worldy song”. What I wasn’t feeling was that warm peaceful feeling from God that I would normally get from Hymns. That’s when I got curious and came across your post.
Your post has given me a completely new perspective of CCM and I now have a better understanding of it. I just wasn’t able to pinpoint why it didn’t feel right to listen to this even though I liked it.
I’m sorry if my comment seems fast-paced or has grammatical errors. Thank you very much for writing this.
Evelyn Fonseca
Thank you for sharing Isaac, comments like this encourage me to keep on writing for His glory! God bless!
Loren Gibel
I enjoyed your article. We are told as Christians not to conform to the world (Romans 12:2) so believe our music style should also be separated to God. I don’t have a huge problem with it viewed as entertainment, as long as the lyrics are Biblically sound and induces wholesome emotions, but I cringe when it is called worship.
I believe the churches in general have embraced entertainment as a form of evangelism to win the world but this is man’s way, not God’s. The Bible teaches us to just plant and water (the seed being his Word), we don’t need to worry about the increase, that’s God’s part (1 Corinthians 3:6).
Hymns were incorporated into church service during the reformation to encourage churchgoers to sing to themselves while working throughout the week. I think we need to keep this in mind when selecting “worship” music, choosing lyrics of good doctrine in a simple tune that’s easy to learn and reflect on.
Evelyn Fonseca
Amen! Yes, sadly, worldly churches use entertainment to help the Holy Spirit reach souls and we are not called to “help” God, but to evangelize and God does the rest. I did not know this about the history of hymns, very interesting thanks for sharing. God bless!
Best SDA Hymnal Songs
Thank you for sharing this profound article! God bless your ministry work for His cause!
https://sdahymnalsongs.com/Hymnal/
Jay
This is a great article. Really sums up the issues with CCM.
Ronnie Safreed
I am a Christian musician & recently walked away from a church worship band because of issues with the worship leader. She literally ran off 4 other female singers & I found out she had ‘issues’ from the pastor. I learned to play guitar as an older child & played in a Pentecostal church. However in my twenties I put the guitar down & back over 20 years ago I picked the guitar up again & also ventured to playing bass, mandolin, ukelele, tenor banjo, hand percussion & song writing. I noticed back 20 years ago how also this tape/cd/computer music has also replaced mucisians. I am not totally against recorded, electronic music but I noticed it is an ‘easy way out’ & ‘you don’t need the hassle of inconsistant mucisians’!!!!! Flighty not dedicated mucisians are a problem & many think they should be paid ‘big money’ to play in the church & I have never been this way!!!! I have seen I have been given a talent & I put it down for a long time & then in my forties picked it back up again & expanded it & this is a miracle to me & I give Yaweh/G-d the glory. BTW I am also in the Messianic aspect
Evelyn Fonseca
Ronnie, thank you for sharing! YAH has blessed you tremendously with much musical talent and praise Him you have used it for His glory. You bring up a good point about electronic music I hadn’t considered before. I think those whom YAH has given musical talent should use it to worship Him alone and lead others in praise to Him.
Joy
Hi Evelyn! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this. I came across your article in a general search about this topic with Christian music. Today, as I was out driving, the thought came to me “I wonder if the ‘Christian’ music I listen to is causing me to draw inwardly.” I have struggled with depression and anxiety since 2013/2014. I have really been focused on myself. A lot lately. I overthink and overanalyze.
I have started noticing in the somewhat recent past that most of the themes for CCM are very generic and, as you said, do not mention God or Jesus. A month or so ago, I was riding in the car with a friend. She was listening to a secular radio station and a song from CCM came on. It kind of shocked me. I was really surprised. I am in my mid to late 30s and so of course I am of a different generation. I did grow up in church, however, singing hymns and also my parents listening to Southern Gospel music. It has not been until the last several months that I have really started to enjoy the hymns from a different perspective. Especially, looking up the history behind the songs. I will say, God has used many CCM songs to speak to my heart, especially when I was having really rough times with depression and anxiety in the beginning. The words spoke in song was what I was feeling, but just did not have the words to describe. (I guess that kind of goes back to the whole ‘self-centeredness’) Thank you again for sharing your thoughts on this. As you and others have said, we must be careful with what we allow into our lives and our ears.. Just because it has anything ‘Christian’ related to it, does not mean that it is.
Evelyn Fonseca
Hello Joy, thank you for sharing your experiences with Christian music. I grew up singing some hymns at church with a mixture of then modern (90s) congregational songs but if I’m honest, I didn’t pay much attention to the hymns. It is only recently, as of a few years ago, that I have acquired a love for hymns, I just wish churches would bring them back instead of playing Hillsong, Bethel, etc all the time. I too, have found some CCM songs to be comforting in the past, but like you said perhaps may be a sign of self-centeredness. It helps to remind ourselves that music is to glorify God and that in our worship to Him we can find peace.
Bryan Lim
I wholeheartedly agree with this article, and though even as a millenial, the world of CCM has always been about the physical “riches” and not centering itself on theology, of which I’d feel that is the substance that is lacking in most “New Age” CCMs today.
Not to bash on the big names (a.k.a Hillsong, Elevation, Bethel and many others), the songs written over the years was sorely lacking on glorifying God, and more of the rekindlement of the congregation-style worship that only bends one way (that isn’t praise, as much as worship is concerned). Correct me if I’m wrong, but songs these days just aren’t my taste anymore, and like you, I’ve begun to turn to songs from tradition (e.g. CFNI, Hosanna! Music) and even Indie bands (e.g. Rivers & Robots) for growing sources of inspiration.
In a nutshell, glorify God the best way you can, and don’t follow the crowd.
songwriter
In the 2000s I attended a master class on how to write CCM music. Imagine my shock when I heard the teacher say to try not to use the name Jesus or be “too preachy.” I was very clear to me that CCM was about more about making money than glorifying God.
Evelyn Fonseca
Wow that is crazy but not surprising. It’s sad that the music industry cares only about making a profit than glorifying God.
Helene
I totally agree that a lot of what we sing in church does have lyrics that are questionable. And that what we listen to/sing is important as it is so influential on our beliefs and feelings. But I’m sad you feel that way about “Oceans”, as the first time I heard it, I thought “that was the way I felt when I had to journey with…..(a family member who had cancer).
Don’t however stop speaking the truth.
Teri
I agree with your article and have many times wished that I could communicate these same thoughts as clearly. I grew up in the seventies and have enjoyed my fair share of CCM via concerts, albums, & radio. This one thing should not be forgotten: Just because it plays well over the air does not mean it plays well in the church. Not every song on the radio is appropriate for congregational singing.
Best advice: “Be careful what you allow your ears to hear.”
Evelyn Fonseca
Yes! Thank you for bringing this up. I agree completely!
Amy Schlege
If you like CCM, you should listen to Rich Mullins! No has ever written more powerful contemporary lyrics than his! You also need to stop Catholic bashing. The liturgical music of the Catholic church includes some of the music beautiful hymns and music ever written!
Evelyn Fonseca
I love Rich Mullins! I listen to his music often. And it’s not bashing, it’s stated truth. I don’t doubt that Catholicism has some beautiful hymns, it’s their doctrines I cannot accept as Biblical. It’s not bashing if it’s true.
seely
Thank you…I stumbled across your article while searching for traditional hymns to play while I worked. I know that often when I listen to a lot of today’s music, I don’t feel joy or peace or any connection to God. There’s often something “missing”…I guess that is the connection to God. Not that there aren’t some exceptions. Thanks again.
Evelyn Fonseca
Thank you for sharing!
Harold B Jackson
The issue is not a musical issue, but rather it’s a covenant issue. The Old Covenant was a physical covenant. (circumcision, sacrifices, tabernacle, the priesthood, the priestly garments.) Under the New Covenant, we are the circumcision, not of the flesh, but of the heart. We are the temple of God. We are the priesthood and our garments is Christ. Under the New Covenant, we are only authorized to sing because all of us are instruments of praise. Under the Old Covenant, God authorized His people to use mechanical instruments and He also specified the instruments to be used, Under the New Covenant He also specified the type of songs and the instruments to be played, the human heart and the spirit.
Evelyn Fonseca
I had never heard this perspective before, you’ve given me much to meditate upon. Thank you for sharing this.
Harold B Jackson
After Adam and Eve sinned, the Lord called out, “Where are you?” Adam said, “I was naked, so I hid myself.” And God said, “Who told you that you were naked?” Lets apply this narrative to this discussion. “Who told you to use mechanical instruments of music to worship God?” Jesus said they that worship God, must worship Him in spirit and in truth. Of all the gifts that God gave to the church, non of those gifts included “the gift of music.” Eph. 5:19 says that we are to communicate God’s truth by sing and making melody with our hearts. Col. 3:16 says we are to teach and admonish each other by singing with thankfulness in out hearts to the Lord. Heb. 13:15 says that we offer up praise to God with the fruit of our lips. We are the instruments of praise, not some mechanical instrument created by man, but created by God. We are the only instrument that God has created that has a spirit and heart to make music all by itself.
Ray Nenow
I fully agree with your article and may even take it further. I was involved in CCM from the Jesus Movement on. I owned, formed and distributed music under the labels of Refuge Records. Home to Joe English, Will MacFarlane, Rick Cua, Jeruslem and many more. I signed Newsboys to their first recording contract. I also started the first “Christian?” Heavy Metal Label. Pure Metal Records. I was given truth in the late 80’s early 90’s and left CCM. I have spent a great deal of time repenting and allowing God to bring deliverance to me in many areas of my life. We want to get back to what pleases God not what pleases our flesh. The majority of music I created was remakes of all my idols of the 60’s and 70’s and in some cases signing them to actual recording contracts. The music was for me not God!
Philippians 2:13 Amplified Bible, Classic Edition (AMPC)
13 [Not in your own strength] for it is God Who is all the while [effectually at work in you [energizing and creating in you the power and desire], both to will and to work for His good pleasure and satisfaction and delight.
Evelyn Fonseca
Thank you for sharing! This is an invaluable comment. God bless.
Chestener
Well stated and well said. I agree. I don’t listen to what passes for Christian music today. I find so many points you made is why. I was raised ** Baby Boomer here** on hymns and when I took responsibility for myself there were wonderful Christian musicians creating music. As mentioned..Keith Green, Bryan Duncan, Carman, Helen Baylor, Russ Taff, Crystal Lewis and others. I still listen to them today..praise and worship that I have listened to for over 20 years. Thank you.